Sixteen Years Later, DEM Continues to Allow Illegal Quarry Activity Near Popular Conservation Area
January 20, 2020
WEST GREENWICH, R.I. — Hopkins Hill Sand & Stone LLC, a quarry on New London Turnpike that borders the Big River Management Area, has been operating without a Rhode Island pollutant discharge elimination system permit for 16 years.
Nearly two years ago ecoRI News unintentionally filed a runoff complaint against the Cardi Corp. subsidiary with the Rhode Island Department of Environmental Management (DEM). During a hike on April 17, 2018 with a concerned Rhode Island resident, Cliff Vanover, plenty of evidence of runoff damage was observed in the 8,319-acre South County conservation area, including accumulating silt on rocks and stream beds and out-of-place gravel and stones that could only be classified as washed-away quarry debris.
When ecoRI News asked DEM for comment about the situation, the state agency responded by logging our media inquiry as a complaint and saying it would conduct an inspection of the site. It did, on May 4, 2018, and found that Hopkins Hill Sand & Stone “is currently discharging stormwater associated with industrial activity and process water associated with sand and gravel washing operations.”
Some 20 months later DEM is still investigating, even though the state has long known the business is illegally discharging waste runoff.
Gail Mastrati, assistant to the director, recently told ecoRI News that the investigation is still ongoing. When asked when the investigation is expected to be finished, she wrote in a Jan. 10 email that, “Every investigation is different and therefore we do not have a timetable, but will be happy to keep you updated on any developments. I hope this is helpful.”
On Dec. 17 of last year, Vanover received an email from a DEM technical staff assistant noting that the “case is still under investigation.”
Even though DEM has said it hasn’t received any runoff complaints concerning Hopkins Hill Sand & Stone — Vanover told ecoRI News he filed two complaints two years ago and initially complained about the matter in 2003 — the state agency knows the quarry has been operating without a Rhode Island pollutant discharge elimination system (RIPDES) permit since fall 2004.
A June 14, 2018 letter of noncompliance sent to Hopkins Hill Sand & Stone by DEM noting that the company is in violation of the federal Clean Water Act and state law also makes reference to another letter sent nearly 14 years earlier (Oct. 13, 2004) that notified Hopkins Hill Road LLC that it needed “to apply for and receive approval from the DEM RIPDES program for the permitting of stormwater discharges associated with industrial activity.”
A subsequent DEM letter sent about a month later extended the company’s RIPDES application deadline to Aug. 27, 2018. A letter dated Oct. 26, 2018 was written in response to Hopkins Hill Sand & Stone’s RIPDES application. The letter noted five deficiencies that need to be corrected before the application can be considered. It also noted that “any discharges from this site are unpermitted and subject to appropriate enforcement.”
Hopkins Hill Sand & Stone had until Dec. 1, 2018 to respond to DEM’s deficiency letter. An email sent last week by Mastrati said the company still hasn’t responded more than a year later.
“No response to the deficiency letter has been received and no permit has been issued,” she wrote.
Hopkins Hill Sand & Stone sells washed concrete sand, washed asphalt sand, bank gravel, and pond fill, among other products. The mining operation also does onsite blasting.
The main objective for any activity that is allowed on the Big River Management Area is the protection of drinking-water quality, according to a 1996 land-use study of the conservation area. The study also noted that land use shouldn’t adversely impact water quality and must consider the impact a use has on the environment and proper maintenance of plant and animal habitat.
The Big River Management Area, which is owned by the Rhode Island Water Resources Board and managed by DEM, features several ponds and rivers, many streams, and important freshwater wetlands.
During that hike with Vanover two springs ago, along one side of a paved road to the mining operation — the side nearest the DEM-managed property and depicted in the above photo — was a small desert of quarry sand. A noticeable path of this blasted and crushed debris stretched into the woods. Further into the woods, fencing installed by Hopkins Hill Sand & Stone to stop runoff from its quarry washing into the Big River Management Area was buried under rocks and silt.
Who are the State representatives and Senators in the area?
What will it take to get the State to start enforcing environmental laws, again? DEM and CRMC were once valiant activists at the forefront of protecting our natural resources.
There should be an independent review board to handle citizens concerns in a PUBLIC forum. There is no way to determine the number and possible inter-relation of citizen’s concerns.
Elect a governor who will better fund these critical agencies and restore an adequate number of staff.
Where is the "Or else" factor to the sand and gravel operation after that many years of non-compliance? Why are they allowed to continue the operation rather than being forced to shut down until everything is brought into compliance? If inadequate fines are imposed, the sand and gravel operation will consider it "the price of doing business".
I hope the state does not do any work with any of these companies
I do not understand DEM’s priorities. They are all over you like storm troopers if you have a under sized clam, but this company is blatantly polluting, and they are dragging their ass about it.
Cardi, need not say anymore as to why no actions by either then to address/respond to the allegations, or ridem to pursue escalating enforcement action for non-compliance. Pretty cut and dry, major land distance activity without permit, black and white.
Where does the town stand in all this, any local ordinance that prohibits mining/quarry operations? They should have some skin in the game or some chips on table with respect to this activity occurring right under their noses.
Seems like a job for The Monkey Wrench Gang.