It Doesn’t Take Much Road Salt to Harm Aquatic Life
Rhode Island dumps a staggering amount on its roads
December 26, 2019
Winter is here, and with it the tried and true method for keeping roads from becoming slippery: salt.
Salting roads as a method of preventing ice from forming began in 1938 in New Hampshire and has become the go-to method for safe winter driving. It’s effective. According to a 1992 study from Marquette University, salting the roads reduced winter car accidents by 87 percent.
While it’s an effective method for safer winter driving, throwing tons of salt down comes with side effects. When cavalries of trucks start to season the roads, they also inadvertently contaminate freshwater wetlands.
“Road salt can travel up to 170 meters [558 feet] from the road across the landscape into wetlands like vernal pools,” said Nancy Karraker, an associate professor of wetland ecology and herpetology at the University of Rhode Island.
Karraker has been studying the impacts of road salt on vernal pools and freshwater wetlands for years and has concerns about salt’s effects on the invertebrates that make fresh water their home.
“Through experiments, I found that wood frogs’ eggs and their tadpoles were only affected at the highest salinity concentration, so they were a little bit more resilient,” she said. “But with the spotted salamanders, there was a significant decline in survival of both eggs and tadpoles with the average concentration of salt we were seeing at vernal pools near roads.”
And getting an average, or even high, concentration of salt in the water is easier to do than you might think.
“If you think about the head of a penny, if you cover half of the head of that penny with rock salt, dump that into a quart of water and stir it until it dissolves, that’s the salt concentration that is harmful to spotted salamanders,” Karraker said. “And if you completely cover the head of a penny and let a little bit spill over the side, and dump that in a quart of water, that’s the amount that harms wood frogs. So it’s a tiny amount of salt, it’s a very low concentration that impacts these animals.”
Rhode Island doesn’t just use a pinch of salt to season its roads. From 2005 to 2013, Rhode Island roads received an average of 516 pounds of salt per lane mile annually, according to a 2014 report by the Rhode Island Department of Administration’s Division of Planning.
Nationwide, an estimated 10 million to 20 million tons of salt is dumped on roads annually — about 120 pounds for every American. Though many states, including Rhode Island, are turning to brine — a mixture of water and salt — instead of chunky crystals, for Karraker a salt by any other name still tastes as salty.
“A salt is a salt is a salt — it doesn’t matter if you’re talking about sodium chloride, magnesium chloride, potassium chloride, and brining just means that you’ve got a salt solution that’s been diluted a bit with water so you can spray it on the road so it acts more quickly to limit ice buildup.”
Karraker hopes that the state departments of environmental management and transportation will consider having “no salt” designations for roads that are near freshwater wetlands.
“You see these signs that say, ‘low road salt use’ near public drinking water sources and I wish they would do the same for biodiversity,” she said. “Why couldn’t we designate certain roads around our wildlife management areas as low road salt use areas to protect biodiversity? Why can’t we start to think about protecting biodiversity like we think about protecting our drinking water? I think it’s important.”
Join the DiscussionView Comments
Your support keeps our reporters on the environmental beat.
Reader support is at the core of our nonprofit news model. Together, we can keep the environment in the headlines.
Another consequence of the drive-everywhere-in-a-hurry culture, worse in Rhode Island where the Providence Journal just had a story that we use the most salt per lane mile of any state! It also pointed out the damage salt does to roads and bridges, and cars too. And its not just aquatic life that is affected, increasing salinity in the Scituate reservoir which has (in 2018 report) now crept up to 16.7 parts per million can be of concern to those with high blood pressure. There are no official standards but I’ve read that 20 parts/million is concerning. Providence Water once had potassium chloride used for deicing near the reservoir which is apparently less of a public health risk than sodium chloride, but it was deemed too expensive.
Thanks for this important and timely article. Don’t forget about the impact of roadsalts on our groundwater! Just in case amphibians or infrastructure don’t motivate us, this story eventually comes full circle through our wells, drinking water, and back to us. Our state needs a coherent database of wells contaminated with road salts! We also need to be exploring other solutions to safer winter driving….
I don’t understand why they have to use salt when sand does just as good a job and does not damage all our bridges and not hurt environmentally.
I read Karraker’s research back in 2013 out of concern about a wetlands near where Colbea has since built a car wash, convenient store and gas station in Cumberland, Rhode Island https://loe.org/images/content/090220/Karraker_et_al_2008.pdf . It appears my correspondence on this matter is lost. I have also recently researched road salt, due to the Blackstone River possibly supplying some with electricity generated by Hydro electricity. Below are from a two speeches I wrote …….
"A word of caution, I hope …… does not plan on using Acetate-based deicers nor Carbohydrate deicers as both are said to severely harm or kill aquatic life.
http://www.planning.ri.gov/documents/LU/RoadSaltTechPaper2013_12114rev.pdf . "
"Also, I must note that deicing still mentions the possible use of road salt, but not specifically noting if they will be using biodegradable products like Glycerol, Ethylene Glycol, or Propylene Glycol as mentioned in https://www.dot.state.mn.us/research/TRS/2014/TRS1411.pdf ."
p.s. I have to wonder if the molasses used in road salt/sand application also pollutes Mother Earth’s waters after having read about a mishap near Hawaii, which was said to of killed coral http://www.hawaiireporter.com/matson-to-pay-1-million-for-honolulu-molasses-spill-under-plea-agreement/. Researched this web site after having listened to a radio show, Science Friday that spoke about efforts to save Coral.
FYI: Did you know sunscreen lotions are killing the coral?https://www.sciencefriday.com/segments/degrees-of-change-reviving-fading-corals/