Just Say No to Bottled Water


Collectively, we Rhode Islanders can put a stop to bottled water being served at local environmental meetings, stop it from being omnipresent at every Statehouse hearing and help curtail this doozy:

The Danone Group, a French multinational company, sells its plastic bottle-encased mineral water, Evian, in an aluminum aerosol mister so consumers can conveniently “refresh” their faces. This spray that “you can feel good about using” comes in different sizes — your spray needs likely dependent on your face size — with the 1.7-ounce, palm-size mister selling for about $6. At that price, a half-liter plastic bottle of Evian would cost $55, or about $427 a gallon, noted author Charles Fishman in his 2011 book “The Big Thirst.”

According to promotional material from the Danone Group, “Evian Mineral Water Spray is sealed at the source. It cannot be contaminated, and will never leak. What’s more, Evian is propelled by environmentally safe nitrogen, won’t harm the ozone layer, and it’s recyclable. Evian Mineral Water Spray — serious skin care provided by nature.”

We gobble up this marketing b.s. and buy tap water in a can to spray on our pampered faces. It’s no coincidence that Evian is spelled “naïve” backward. We are green — and not in a good way — about the importance of water. We take it for granted.

In his excellent book, Fishman notes there’s a facility near an aquifer on the isolated north coast of Fiji’s main island that fills more than a million plastic bottles of FIJI Water a day. This water is trucked and shipped all over the world. Meanwhile, as these plastic bottles filled with water from an island aquifer are loaded onto cargo ships so thirsty Providence residents 8,000 miles away can avoid the bubbler, more than half of Fiji’s citizens lack access to safe, reliable drinking water.

Americans drink a combined billion bottles of water a week. The three largest brands of bottled water — Nestle Pure Life, Coke’s Dasani and Pepsi’s Aquafina — are municipal tap water, repurified and sold back to us in plastic bottles. We keep buying it, even in Providence, where a 2009 study by the Environmental Working Group found our capitol to have some of the best tap water in the country.

In fact, tap water is more closely regulated and monitored than bottled water, although that fact is lost in the marketing of bottled water as a cleaner, healthier alternative to the tap.

In 2011, the Environmental Working Group analyzed the labels of 173 bottled-water products and company websites to determine if companies disclose information on where water comes from, how or if their water is treated, and whether the results of purity testing are revealed. Researchers also followed up by calling dozens of bottled-water companies to find out which ones willingly tell consumers what’s in their bottles. Half of the products surveyed failed the group’s transparency test — 18 percent didn’t say where their water comes from and another 32 percent didn’t disclose any information on treatment or purity of water.

Tap water, however, is regularly tested and consumers can find local water information online.

Avoiding bottled water is one way we can take better care of water resources, locally and globally. The Ocean State should be at the forefront of a “Just Say No to Bottled Water” movement.

ecoRI News challenges all Rhode Islanders to get off bottled water. Stop handing out pallets of it at every road race in the state. There’s plenty of better ways to rehydrate runners without giving them water in a throwaway plastic bottle with a massive carbon footprint.

Panelists don’t need a bottle or two placed at their seats before a talk at the University of Rhode Island or Brown University about climate change. A pitcher of water and some glasses work just fine.

The state’s legion of outstanding environmental nonprofits shouldn’t be offering water in individual plastic vessels. No one is going to suffer from dehydration during a workshop or monthly meeting. Rhode Island features plenty of drinking foundations and glass pitchers to handle any thirst.

We challenge our elected officials to stop spending about $18,000 annually to provide bottled water at the Statehouse. Thirsty senators and representatives can bring a reusable mug to work and fill it with renowned Providence tap water.

In fact, we challenge all state agencies and institutions to stop the unnecessary purchase of water in plastic bottles, unless in an emergency.

Frank Carini is the editor of ecoRI News.


Join the Discussion

View Comments

Recent Comments

  1. Good post. Its ironic to me, having lived in places with lower quality of public tap water (for example in Florida) that there is so much bottled water in RI. I suggest that this article be rpinted and sent to the State House, and perhaps distributed to the non-profit community, farmers markets and the like. Its not enough just to tell it to oursleves!

  2. It is imperative we move forward and stop using bottled water. I'm puzzled that Rhode Island, with all its beautiful beaches, is one of the few states with no bottle bill. Let's step on board and help beautify "The Ocean State" in every way we can.

  3. Good initiative! In our house we bought a table top distiller and we have been using it for 4+ years. It has paid for itself many times over, supplying us with gallons and gallons of great drinking water, bottle free. It is my favorite appliance (next to the coffee maker).

  4. Although I agree that the bottled water consumption is a problem, I'm surprised that Providence's water rated so well by EWG. It tastes horrendous, as does most of the water I've had in RI cities. Also, municipal water supplies contain fluoride, which is not actually healthy for consumption. I feel like it's a bit of a no-win situation.

  5. Becki, you can buy a water filter pitcher or a water filtration system for a home tap(s). Drinking water that is sitting in plastic bottles that leach can't be better for you than tap water with fluoride. I'd be more concerned about drinking from plastic bottles.

    — Frank Carini, ecoRI News executive director

  6. Not to be a troll, but I question Becki's perception of taste, if she does *not* like Providence tap water but instead prefers inhaling the aroma of plastic with each sip of water.

    Also, the CDC considers fluoridation one of the top 10 greatest public health initiatives of the 20th century: http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/00056796.htm. Many people — including those who lack ready access to dental care — have higher quality lives because of the protection fluoridation provides.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Your support keeps our reporters on the environmental beat.

Reader support is at the core of our nonprofit news model. Together, we can keep the environment in the headlines.


We use cookies to improve your experience and deliver personalized content. View Cookie Settings